Similar to: Haden Heritage Toaster

Top Picks

Digital Toaster with Express Finish
Top Pick

Best high-speed toaster for busy mornings needing precise, consistent results.

This is the rare toaster that actually respects your morning schedule, prioritizing speed without sacrificing the precision of digital browning controls. While you trade off the tactile satisfaction of a manual lever for a streamlined, modern interface, you gain consistent, perfectly browned results every single time.

Fast Toasting

Digital Control

Defrost/Reheat

Wide Slots

KitchenAid KMT2116CU Toaster
Runner-Up

Best two-slice toaster for those who enjoy bagels and artisan breads.

This is the workhorse your countertop deserves, prioritizing sturdy, stainless steel reliability over unnecessary digital gimmicks. While it lacks fancy smart-home connectivity, its extra-wide slots and precise browning controls ensure your morning bagel is toasted exactly how you like it every single time.

Wide Slots

Custom Browning

Reheat

Defrost

Best retro-style toaster for design-conscious kitchens needing versatile, everyday performance.

This toaster leans heavily into mid-century aesthetics, proving that your countertop appliances can be as stylish as they are functional. While it prioritizes vintage charm and wide slots for thick bagels, you sacrifice a bit of counter space for its robust, retro-inspired footprint.

Retro Design

Wide Slots

Even Toasting

Browning Control

Best two-slice toaster for home cooks seeking precision and consistent results.

Best premium toaster for home cooks seeking precise, customized browning results.