Similar to: Proctor Silex Toaster

Top Picks

KitchenAid Toaster
Top Pick

Best versatile toaster for households needing customized, simultaneous toasting.

This is the reliable workhorse for households that refuse to compromise on breakfast variety. While it lacks the flashy digital displays of modern competitors, it trades complexity for rock-solid consistency and extra-wide slots that actually handle thick bagels without jamming. It’s a straightforward, dependable upgrade for anyone tired of uneven browning.

Dual Controls

Wide Slots

Bagel Setting

High Lift

Black+Decker TR1470BD Toaster
Runner-Up

Best four-slice toaster for busy households needing versatile, everyday breakfast convenience.

This four-slice workhorse prioritizes utility over complexity, making it the ideal choice for busy households that need consistent results without the fuss. While it lacks high-end customization, the extra-wide slots and dedicated bagel settings offer the reliability needed to handle everything from thick sourdough to frozen waffles with ease.

Wide Slots

Bagel Function

Reheat/Defrost

Browning Control

Best stylish toaster for design-conscious kitchens needing versatile, even browning.

This appliance is less about utility and more about making a statement on your countertop. While you are paying a premium for that iconic mid-century aesthetic, the wide slots and precise browning controls ensure the performance actually matches the striking looks.

Retro Design

Wide Slots

Even Toasting

Browning Control

Best four-slice toaster for busy households needing precise, customizable breakfast results.

Best four-slice toaster for busy households needing versatile, independent toasting control.